Taking too long? Close loading screen.
November 01, 2016
Questioning the sustainability of recent civil society initiatives to help refugees
Αn in-depth discussion on sustainability seems to be more necessary than ever. How do we know though that in five years’ time we won’t be here again, talking about the same things?
November 01, 2016

There has been a significant rise in new initiatives addressing the refugee crisis in the Mediterranean region in the past year and a half, including both structured and more informal organizations and activities. The many different initiatives that have sprung up within a short time raise an important concern: are they sustainable solutions or simply “fireworks” that are attractive and intense for a short duration, but quickly fizzle out, leaving behind ashes and debris?

I founded Solomon magazine, a digital publication based in Greece that is run by a team of 24 people from diverse backgrounds, with 18 languages spoken among them. The magazine is both an integration initiative reclaiming refugees’ and asylum seekers’ skills and talents, and a way for host communities to understand issues from the perspective of refugees.

I recently participated in a panel examining the role of more improvised or atypical initiatives that have emerged during the refugee crisis, which was organized by the Onassis Cultural Centre. A recurring theme during the discussion was:

“How do we know that in five years’ time we won’t be here again, talking about these same issues?”

This is a soul-searching question for those of us who started and manage small-scale initiatives, and an important moment for introspection and improvement.

What is the problem that we think we are solving? Is there actually a problem and if so, whose problem is it? Have we actually asked the people facing the problem what their needs are before handing out solutions? There are some fundamental mistakes we must avoid to effectively provide a solution to a specific problem. First, there is often the tendency to carry out projects to aid a certain group of people, without first asking them what their needs are.

Second, the philosophy behind most social integration programs seems to be, “I’m carrying out this project for refugees.” With this philosophy, you’ve failed before you’ve begun. Integration is a mutual process with benefits for both sides – host communities and refugees.

Third, we often provide “fireworks” – in the form of impressive events or exhibits – until the budget has been used up and we are unable to carry out programs until new funding becomes available. It is useless to start a program without a long-term commitment to creating lasting impact, regardless of the scale.

Finally, when obtaining funding becomes a driving motivation and the mission is simply being involved in a “trendy” cause that is
attractive to funders, this raises a moral predicament. The most important question we must ask ourselves is also the most difficult one:

Do we really want to solve a problem or have we realized we’ll only get funding if we find a problem to solve?

Failing to be honest about this can be harmful. If a project launches, but six months later is not able to renew funding, will we then simply abandon the refugees who were receiving services such as education, psychosocial support, microfinance and legal counseling? For the sake of consistency, all initiatives must have a financial plan so that they are able to sustain themselves, remain independent of the dispositions of funders and prioritize serving people in need. Ultimately, the question of how we avoid being back at square one in five years’ time depends on how much we collaborate with the people at the heart of the crisis.

For example, as someone who is not a refugee, I will only ever have an approximate idea of the needs of displaced communities, no matter how long I research the issue, how many diplomas I earn on the topic or how much I work in the field of migration.

Related ›

Testimonies of refugees and migrants in a time of pandemic

The digital narratives were created under the project “Narrating COVID-19: Testimonies from Refugees and Migrants in a Time of Pandemic”, which was implemented by the MSc “Global Health – Disaster Medicine” of School of Medicine, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens (NKUA), in order to highlight the humanitarian role of new technologies, which has been used as a tool of self-expression to capture the psychosocial effects of Covid-19 in vulnerable populations.

Sex work can be a choice

Despite objections, some people believe they have the right to get paid for having sex. Sex workers share their stories.

<a href="https://solomonmag.com/author/fanis/" target="_self">Fanis Kollias</a>

Fanis Kollias

Author

What do you think about this piece? This is an open discussion and we’d love to read your thoughts.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

five − 2 =

More to read

Related
Name: Unknown – Cause of death: Drowning

Name: Unknown – Cause of death: Drowning

“I can’t, I’ve had a difficult time processing all this.” Since 2012, the registrar of Lesvos has been mainly registering the bodies of unidentified refugees.

Testimonies of refugees and migrants in a time of pandemic

Testimonies of refugees and migrants in a time of pandemic

The digital narratives were created under the project “Narrating COVID-19: Testimonies from Refugees and Migrants in a Time of Pandemic”, which was implemented by the MSc “Global Health – Disaster Medicine” of School of Medicine, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens (NKUA), in order to highlight the humanitarian role of new technologies, which has been used as a tool of self-expression to capture the psychosocial effects of Covid-19 in vulnerable populations.

You'll love your inbox!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates, follow the discussion and stay in touch with our team.

Almost done! Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

By browsing on our website you accept our cookies policy. More info

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close